Can A Science Fiction Like Geo-Engineering Solution Combat Climate Change?

Don Wood  – MessageToEagle.com – A controversial and much-debated geo-engineering solution may combat climate change, scientists suggest.

The solution that sounds almost like science fiction has already been tested. According to researchers both sea-ice retreat and global warming could be slowed by using millions of wind-powered pumps, drifting in the sea ice, to promote ice formation during the Arctic winter.

Frozen and snow-covered meltwater ponds on Arctic sea ice. (Photo: AWI, Stefan Hendricks)

The idea is based on ten million wind-powered pumps, distributed throughout the Arctic that are intended to promote the formation of sea ice in the winter.

They would continually pump seawater onto the surface of the ice, where it would freeze. The now-thicker ice could then survive the summertime melting longer and therefore reflect sunlight longer where otherwise the darker ocean would readily take up the sun’s warming rays. This could not only slow the loss of Arctic sea ice, but also mitigate remote impacts, perhaps even the warming in lower latitudes

Scientists from the Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research explain that from a purely physical standpoint, the near-total loss of summertime sea ice, which will likely come by mid-century in the ‘business-as-usual’ scenario, could indeed be pushed back to the end of the century. However, this grace period would not entail any significant cooling for the climate in Europe or around the globe.

“Normally the growth of the ice is limited by the fact that, as it becomes thicker, the ice increasingly insulates the ocean from the winter cold; for this reason, typically you won’t find an overall thickness of more than a few meters. But the pumps do away with this limiting effect, because new layers are added to the ice from above,” Helge Goessling, head of the research group, explains.

See also:

Drones Observe Dangerous Fractures Causing Rapid Draining Of Lakes On Greenland Ice Sheet

Nine Climate Tipping Points Are Now Active – Scientists Warn

Insects Could Be Wiped Out Within A Century – Alarming Report

Bad News: Surface Melting Causes Antarctic Glaciers To Slip Faster Towards The Ocean

More About Earth Changes

Initial simulations based on pumps churning seawater onto the ice throughout the Arctic show: year after year, the ice would gain between one and two metres in thickness. According to the climate model, the global warming produced by CO₂ wouldn’t put an end to this growth until the end of the century. And what about the effects on the climate?

The summertime warming of the Arctic would in fact be lessened by several degrees Celsius, as projected in the original publication. However, pumping the comparatively warm (-1.8 °C) water would also alter the thermal flow in winter, resulting in a substantial warming of the Arctic in winter. This thermal energy would also be transported to the middle latitudes and stored in the ocean there.

In the next step, the researchers conducted more realistic simulations in which the pumps were only deployed where the ice was less than two metres thick.

“Two-metre-thick ice already has the best chances of surviving the summertime melting, and by limiting the distribution of pumps in this way, the unnecessary and considerable wintertime warming can also be avoided,” says Lorenzo Zampieri. In this scenario, the undesirable additional warming of the middle latitudes could in fact be avoided, but the scheme would still do little to mitigate climate change.

Arctic pack ice with frozen meltwater ponds and press ice ridges. (Photo: AWI, Stefan Hendricks)

Though the warming of the Arctic in summer would be reduced by roughly one degree Celsius, and the loss of the sea ice could be delayed by roughly 60 years, the increased reflection of sunlight wouldn’t be sufficient to slow climate change outside the Arctic.

“Given the unchecked progression of climate change to date, geo-engineering can’t be dismissed as mere nonsense by the climate research community,” claims Helge Goessling. Instead, these ideas need to be subjected to scientific scrutiny. Arctic ‘ice management’, both authors agree, is interesting in its own right, but can’t meaningfully mitigate global climate change; as such, it should remain science fiction.

Written by Don Wood – MessageToEagle.com Staff